Updates From The Ministry Of Fixing That Which Ain’t Broke
In February of 2005, we reported with shock and outrage that the Ontario government had issued an RFP to replace Ontario’s elegant, classic and functional wordmark and logo:
The Ontario logo is about clarity and efficiency. That’s precisely what government should be about — not glitzy marketing and sex-appeal. It looks authoritative enough to go on a badge. The pretty Tourism Ontario logo — probably the kind of thing the gub’mint is looking for in its RFP — would look stupid printed onto a traffic ticket or park ranger’s uniform. Besides, the [current] stylized logo, with its rounded containing box, is easily identifiable even in the absence of any text.
Well, a year and a half later, and they finally did it: They relegated a classic design to the logo cemetary, ushering in a thorny-looking and most unflowerlike looking trillium made up of human forms stolen from the Special Olympics logo. It’s like the Downsview Park logo with its hair in a spike.
As we expected, it’s glitzier than the old one, and less functional, too. And, of course, they managed to burn through nearly a quarter-million on the redesign. And who better to hire for the job than Bensimon-Byrne — whose client roster also includes, surprise surprise, the Ontario Liberal Party.
The CBC notes with interest that since running Dalton’s election ad campaign, the agency has received $6 million in contracts from the Liberal government. The NDP called foul on the agency’s last gubmint deal, for the stupid.ca anti-smoking ad contract.
Update:
A Toronto Star reader nails it:
“What a wasteful use of taxpayers’ dollars. For 40 years, our logo has been a simple, classic trademark. Now we have some stylized, easy-to-outdate logo, suspicious in its design. Reverse your field on this one, Dalton. Goodness knows, you’ve done it on enough other issues.”
oERICo
June 24, 2006 12:33 pm
it looks like ontario is trying to get hip and edgy. Nothing like seducing the extreme sports crowd a decade too late.
Mr. greyfedora goes to Washington » Blog Archive » Rebranding Ontari-ari-ario
June 25, 2006 5:00 am
[…] Yes, Ontario taxpayers have shelled out $219,000 for a new logo that looks like a trillium being blown up by a stick of dynamite. OptimusCrime identifies the creator as an advertising agency, Bensimon-Byrne, that includes the Liberal party among its clients. […]
OPTIMUSCRIME.COM » Attention Dalton: A Government Is, Alas, Not An ‘Entrepreneurial Organization’
June 26, 2006 9:21 am
[…] A hilarious defence from Queen’s Park on Trilliumgate. Says McGuinty: “I think that as an $80-billion organization that’s trying to comwpete with the best in the world, it’s really important that from time to time we refresh our outlook, our logo, how we present ourselves,” he said. “It’s just something that is done by every single proactive entrepreneurial organization and that’s what we’re trying to be.” […]
canadian design resource » Toronto Zoo logo
June 27, 2006 10:48 am
[…] This redesign of the Toronto Zoo logo (top) succeeds in cleverly updating the original (bottom) without destroying what’s become a well recognized icon - Harder than it looks. […]
Tony Goff
June 30, 2006 6:51 am
Not quite as bad as the Quark fiasco but then that didn’t use up tax payers money. For better of worse it also radically changed its font which is more then can be said for the blink and you’ll miss it font change on this one…